Gananoque mayor defends tax hike in online exchange

Gananoque Mayor John Beddows has responded with unapologetic candor to a pointed question from a resident fed up with rising taxes and the price of a bag of leaves.
The question came from Dave Hall, a local who had had enough.
“If the town is going broke just say so,” he posted publicly, accusing council of either panicking or pulling a money grab with property tax hikes and a newly implemented bag tag requirement for leaf disposal. “Which is it John?”
Town council is expected to vote Tuesday on a bylaw putting in place a tax rate increase of 8.97 per cent.
The mayor, never one to shy from a lengthy explanation or a fight worth having, answered back on Facebook.
“The answer to your question is neither. This isn’t panic. It’s deliberate,” Beddows wrote. “The town isn’t broke, but we need to set conditions so we are able to afford necessary work.”
And with that, the floodgates opened.
What followed was a flood of detail, including capital reserve shortfalls, decade-long infrastructure gaps, and a mayoral pay cut passed by the slimmest of margins. Beddows’ tone was steady, his message uncomfortable but clear: the problems Gananoque faces were born of years of looking the other way.
“As it is, we’re having to borrow money for capital projects and purchases because historically here in Gananoque property tax rates and fees didn’t begin to properly factor for capital depreciation,” he replied. “Gananoque hasn’t done that. We’re in year 21 of the scenario and we’re having to make up for the fact that for 20 years no money was set aside to replace that roof.”
The analogy is a good one, because now, with shingles falling and interest rising, the town is scrambling to catch up.
“When I ran as mayor in 2022, I argued that we had a problem because we had a capital reserve shortfall of about $15 million at that time, and I said that taxes would have to rise,” Beddows said. “I pay the same property taxes and fees that everyone else does. I also said that I would cut the mayor’s pay by 15 per cent and freeze it there for the duration of the term, which I did.”
He placed the blame on past councils for failing to plan.
“Instead of starting to save money for replacement cost at the beginning of the life of infrastructure by increasing taxes a little bit, prior councils didn’t do that. Now we’re having to make up the difference and for lost time,” he wrote.
Beddows said the town’s approach to budgeting changed under his direction, emphasizing transparency and professionalism over pre-set tax numbers.
“We pay professionals to give us their best view of what is necessary, and they should put that forward publicly,” he said.
Since 2023, capital reserve contributions have risen from 76 per cent of what’s needed to 91 per cent this year, wrote Beddows. That is still not enough, he admitted. Not close.
“The challenge is that we’ve lost the cushion as interest rates have fallen and we’ve spent our reserves,” Beddows wrote.
He pointed to a $4.4-million provincial grant for wastewater infrastructure as a saving grace, but added new provincial regulations have also added weight to the town’s budget.
From sewer inspections to NG911 systems under the new Community Safety and Policing Act, costs are growing, and they’re mandatory.
And as for the infamous bag tags? That, too, was Beddows’ idea.
“In 2024, the town spent a bit over $35,000 in wages for curbside leaf collection. That’s about one-third of one per cent of the tax levy,” he wrote. “Because of the bag fee, the town is collecting $35,000 less in taxes this year.”
“Drop off is still at no cost at the Town Yard and we’re still doing free curbside pickup of brush and branches in the spring and fall. It’s not popular, but the tax is lower because of the bag fee.”
In the end, it came down to one simple question, which the mayor asked repeatedly during budget talks: “Where can we cut service levels?”
Only one cut passed – the leaf pickup. And for that, Beddows isn’t passing the buck.
“It was my suggestion that we could go to a user pay system, and I own my actions always,” he wrote.
