Gananoque waste site was ‘illegal’: Staff

Gananoque council was to consider on Wednesday whether to pursue provincial approval for continued waste operations at the town’s Public Works yard, a site municipal officials describe in a report as having operated as an “illegal waste transfer station.”
The Public Works yard at 665 Charles St. N. was formerly a landfill that operated under environment ministry approval until it was closed Aug. 1, 1972. According to the staff report prepared for council, there is currently no Ministry of the Environment, Conservation and Parks (MECP) approval in place for the site.
The report states that the town subsequently continued accepting various forms of waste at the property without the required environmental approval. Staff specifically characterize the site’s operation as an “illegal waste transfer station.”
The site has been used for leaf and yard waste, e-waste, scrap metal, brush and municipal “Dump Day” disposal events.
Staff now says the town has ceased receiving materials at the site following direction from the MECP.
Council is being asked to select one of three options for the property.
The first would maintain the cessation of transfer-station operations and have staff review a groundwater monitoring plan once it is approved by the province.
The second would direct staff to pursue an Environmental Compliance Approval (ECA) for the site, potentially allowing some or all of the previous waste-management activities to resume.
The third would have staff continue exploring alternative waste disposal and recycling arrangements instead of pursuing an ECA.
The issue arose after an MECP inspection in June 2025 identified that the municipal works yard was being used as a waste transfer site without an ECA under the Environmental Protection Act.
The ministry subsequently required the town to develop an action plan to address the compliance issues.
Staff initially examined whether operational changes could allow some activities to continue under existing exemptions for field operations. However, the town was later advised that groundwater monitoring would be required because of the property’s history as a closed landfill and the continued acceptance of waste at the site after the landfill’s closure.
The town submitted a proposed groundwater monitoring plan to the MECP in May 2026 and is awaiting further direction from the ministry.
The environmental concerns became more immediate in June, when a resident reported liquid seeping from the ground near a trail and flowing toward Stocking Hill Creek.
Town staff reported the matter to the ministry’s Spills Action Centre, collected samples and monitored the area. MECP officials subsequently visited the site and collected their own samples.
The report states the town has not yet received the ministry’s sampling results. Staff continues to monitor the area at the MECP’s request.
The report also notes that a similar groundwater discharge was reported to the Spills Action Centre in 2023.
Meanwhile, the town has been removing material from the site.
One excess-soil stockpile, approximately 195 cubic metres in size, was determined to be contaminated and was removed in 2026 to an approved receiving facility.
Four other stockpiles contain an estimated 2,705 cubic metres of material combined. Staff says further technical review is ongoing and the remaining material may be able to remain on site and be reused under provincial excess-soil regulations.
Leaf, yard and organic waste, along with concrete and asphalt, are also being removed. The town has until Oct. 31 to remove the materials currently on site, following an extension granted by the ministry.
The town has already begun implementing an alternative for leaf and yard waste, with its existing solid-waste contractor expected to provide curbside collection in fall 2026.
Pursuing formal provincial approval for continued waste-transfer operations would not be cheap or quick.
Staff estimates an Environmental Compliance Approval process would cost approximately $100,000 to $250,000 or more, with the process expected to take roughly 12 to 24 months. A more complex approval process could exceed both estimates because of the site’s history as a closed landfill.
The town would also face ongoing costs for groundwater monitoring and reporting estimated at $4,000 to $20,000 annually, along with potential administration, maintenance and reporting costs of another $10,000 to $50,000 annually.
Keith Dempsey is a Local Journalism Initiative reporter who works out of the Brockville Recorder and Times. The Local Journalism Initiative is funded by the Government of Canada.
