The Brockville area's go-to source for local news – covering Brockville, Gananoque, Lansdowne, Mallorytown, and everything in between.

BrockvilleistMunicipalNews

Fiscal accountability, development, leadership centre stage at TLTI council debate

Deputy Mayor Terry Fodey speaks during the Oct. 7 council candidates’ debate at the Lansdowne Community Building, where his comments about experience in the mayor’s office drew criticism from some audience members. – Keith Dempsey/Local Journalism Initiative Reporter

Fiscal responsibility, development, and the importance of asking tough questions were among the central themes as candidates seeking seats on Leeds and the Thousand Islands council gathered for a debate Oct. 7 at the Lansdowne Community Building. 

With 10 candidates competing for six council seats across the township’s three wards, the debate gave residents an opportunity to hear how candidates would approach municipal spending, infrastructure, community engagement and the township’s future. 

The discussion also grew heated over leadership and experience, with Ward 1 Deputy Mayor Terry Fodey drawing a strong reaction from the audience after criticizing the prospect of electing an inexperienced mayor. 

The municipal election is Oct. 26, with advance voting beginning Oct. 16. 

Who is running for council? 

Ten candidates are seeking six council seats in Leeds and the Thousand Islands. 

In Ward 1, where voters will elect three councillors, the candidates are incumbents Terry Fodey and Brian Mabee, along with John Paul (JP) Jackson, Sara Meurling and Todd Robertson. 

Ward 2 has three candidates competing for two seats: incumbent Couns. Monique Antoine-Hartley and Angela Kelman, and Clark Olson. 

In Ward 3, James F. Bernard is challenging incumbent Krista LeClair (Waddell) for one seat. 

Robertson, Antoine-Hartley, Kelman and LeClair were appointed to council during the current term and are now seeking election to the positions they hold. Fodey and Mabee are seeking re-election. 

Spending, accountability and the questions behind decisions 

Questions about how municipal money is spent emerged as a defining theme, particularly in comments from Jackson, who argued that residents deserve clear explanations for major decisions and project costs. 

Jackson pointed to the new Seeley’s Bay Fire Station, the final construction cost of which reached $6.8 million, up from an original budget of $4.2 million. 

“I absolutely support our firefighters having a safe modern facility,” Jackson said, while questioning the cost of the project. 

“I want people around the table who will ask difficult questions, challenge each other respectfully and follow the evidence,” he said. 

Jackson called for greater fiscal responsibility and accountability at the council table, arguing that residents deserve clearer explanations of municipal decisions. 

Fodey, meanwhile, stressed the importance of ensuring that financial incentives connected to new buildings and developments are met. 

James F. Bernard, a small-business owner running in Ward 3, called for what he described as a practical, street-level execution of municipal services and a return to basic business discipline and common sense in the council chamber. 

Bernard said his experience in business had taught him how to get things done, emphasizing practical results and the need to ensure municipal services meet residents’ needs. 

Development, housing and protecting the township 

Candidates also discussed the relationship between development, economic growth and preserving the qualities that make the township attractive to residents. 

Mabee said housing development has improved and argued that growth can help strengthen the local economy. 

Meurling emphasized the importance of protecting the environment as the township grows. 

A Ward 1 candidate and local business owner, Meurling has lived in the township with her husband, Ted Kaiser, since moving from Toronto in 2019. The couple had owned property in the area for years before making the move to Black Rapids. 

Meurling operates Sara’s Boho Vintage in Lansdowne and has been involved in local volunteering, including the Lansdowne Association for Revitalization and community fundraising events. Her professional background includes theatre administration, business management and leadership in the professional theatre sector. 

Robertson said the three issues he hears most often from voters are fiscal responsibility, administrative red tape and the proposed Alto high-speed rail project. 

He said residents want clearer explanations of municipal rules and simpler ways to navigate administrative processes, citing procurement policies and licensing fees as areas where changes or additional education could help. 

Robertson said he opposes the Alto project, arguing that he sees no discernible benefits for township residents. He said he would be open to discussions about improvements to the existing passenger rail system. 

He also identified local jobs and economic development, keeping taxes as low as possible, and road safety and maintenance as important priorities. 

Experience, communication and working together 

Candidates offered differing perspectives on what they would bring to council, but several emphasized communication and the need for councillors to work constructively despite disagreements. 

Mabee, who has served on council for almost nine years and also serves as Gananoque’s Town Crier, said the goal should be a strong, collective council made up of people who are accessible and responsive to residents. 

“We don’t always agree with each other, and that’s misrepresented sometimes,” Mabee said. 

Robertson described public service as a continuing part of his life, saying he sees his current council role as an extension of that commitment. 

Meurling brings experience in business management, finance, human resources, marketing, public relations and advocacy. She previously served as executive director of the Professional Association of Canadian Theatres and held a senior management position with Carbon Computing. 

Bernard said his experience as a small-business owner would bring a practical perspective to municipal decision-making. 

Jackson, who previously served the community on council and remained involved in municipal and community affairs after leaving office, said he wants a council that can debate difficult issues respectfully while remaining focused on residents. 

Fodey’s comments on mayoral experience draw reaction 

The discussion became more heated when Fodey raised the issue of strong mayor powers and the importance of experience in the mayor’s office. 

Fodey noted that TLTI Mayor Corinna Smith-Gatcke had not used strong mayor powers during her time in office, then contrasted the township’s approach with the situation in Gananoque. 

He referred to the substantial legal costs and public tensions associated with the neighbouring town’s mayor and council, suggesting that divisions between a mayor and council can carry significant financial consequences. 

Using hand gestures to illustrate the two sides moving in different directions, Fodey said hundreds of thousands of dollars can be spent when a mayor and council are at odds. 

He also noted that mayors in Ontario municipalities designated for strong mayor powers can have access to significant authority if they choose to use it. 

Fodey then turned to the question of experience in the mayor’s office, saying: “I can’t put a mayor in the mayor’s chair with no experience.” 

The comment drew boos from some in the audience, while one member of the public called it uncalled for. 

Fodey’s remarks were directed at Jason Page, who is running for mayor. The comments drew criticism in part because the Oct. 7 debate was intended for candidates seeking council seats, rather than those running for mayor. 

A choice about the township’s future 

Other candidates also outlined the experience and priorities they would bring to council. 

Ward 2 incumbent Monique Antoine-Hartley, a lifelong Seeley’s Bay resident, was appointed to council in February 2025. Before entering municipal government, she spent 38 years in education, including as an educator and elementary school principal. She has also been involved in community organizations and events, including the Seeley’s Bay Area Residents Association, Frostfest and the Lyndhurst Turkey Fair. 

Kelman has said municipal resources are stretched and council must balance maintaining services and infrastructure with keeping taxes manageable. 

Ward 3 candidate Bernard is seeking a seat against incumbent Krista LeClair, who was appointed in November 2025 following a vacancy. 

Keith Dempsey is a Local Journalism Initiative reporter who works out of the Brockville Recorder and Times. The Local Journalism Initiative is funded by the Government of Canada. 

Leave a Reply